Skill adoption plan: what to take from the GitHub and Reddit surveys

Decision document. Written 2026-08-11. Nothing has been written into any agent knowledge base. This is for your approval first.

Sources: GITHUB-SKILL-FINDS.md and REDDIT-SKILL-FINDS.md, both in this folder. This plan does not repeat them. It checks their recommendations against what your agents already contain and throws out the ones that are duplicates, inapplicable or illegal to use.


The single most useful thing found

skills/ads/references/meta-decision-system.md in coreyhaines31/marketingskills. MIT licensed. It becomes the missing decision-rules section of cannabis-ads-strategist\knowledge.md.

Two reasons, and the second is the one that matters.

One: your ads agent currently has no decision rules at all. I read all 32k of cannabis-ads-strategist\knowledge.md. It has a regulatory clock, a platform policy map, an inventory map, a measurement framework, account facts, a risk and recovery path, creative direction, routing and open questions. It has no section on when to kill an ad, when to scale one, how many creatives a budget supports, or how much spend has to accumulate before a number means anything. The word "kill" never appears as a decision. That is a real hole, not a suspected one.

Two, and this is the actual finding: almost every other good result across both surveys is Meta or Google tactics, and your own knowledge base already establishes that Meta and Google are closed to these brands. Your platform map, verified 2026-08-10 by reading Meta's Transparency Center directly, says THC is banned outright on Meta, CBD needs LegitScript plus written authorization and non-ingestible only, and delta-8 is prohibited. Google Ads is THC-banned, CBD only topical and non-ingestible with LegitScript, and geo-limited to California, Colorado and Puerto Rico. Cali Extrax and TGH Houston do not clear those gates.

That single fact kills most of the survey haul:

Find Survey rank Verdict against your platform map
u/WizardOfEcommerce corpus, Andromeda bottlenecks Reddit #5 Meta creative mechanics. Meta is closed. Skip.
Claude Skills for Google Ads, product-label trap Reddit #8 Google Shopping. Closed to these brands. Skip.
6 months running Meta Ads for dispensaries Reddit #13 One unverifiable post that contradicts a directly-read Meta policy. Skip.
PPC checklist SOP from 2019 Reddit #7 Google Ads era shape. Closed channel. Skip.
meta-decision-system.md GitHub #1 Survives. It is arithmetic over spend and target CPA wearing a Meta label. Nothing in it is Meta-specific.

The reachable inventory in your own section 4 is endemic platforms, cannabis programmatic DSPs (Mantis, Fyllo, MediaJel, Surfside, Traffic Roots), affiliate and SEO. The decision system applies to all of them unchanged, because "how much spend before this placement's number means anything" is the same question on Mantis as on Meta.

I checked the author's statistics rather than trusting them. He claims 3x target cost-per-lead of spend gives about 95% confidence that a zero-conversion ad is genuinely bad, that 2x carries a 13% false-negative rate, and that 5x overpays. At true cost per conversion equal to target, expected conversions at 3x spend is 3, and the probability of observing zero is e^-3 = 4.98%. At 2x it is e^-2 = 13.5%. At 5x it is e^-5 = 0.67%. His three numbers are correct. This is a file that did the work.

The honest catch on it. The kill and keep half needs per-ad conversion data, and your section 6 says the headline live defect on these accounts is broken UTM and attribution. So that half is written now and runs after Ahmed Mustafa fixes tracking. The budget and ceiling half needs only daily budget and a target CPA, and target CPA comes from margin, not from tracking. That half is usable this week.

The arithmetic also gets more forgiving at your scale, not less. His worked example is B2B at a $500 target cost per lead, so 3x is $1,500 to judge one ad. At a hemp DTC target CPA of $40, 3x is $120. His creative ceiling formula, (daily budget x 14) / (2 x target CPA), at $100 a day and $40 CPA gives a ceiling of 17 creatives. That is a usable number for a real cannabis budget.


Take, in priority order

1. Ad decision rules. New section in cannabis-ads-strategist\knowledge.md

Source: coreyhaines31/marketingskills, skills/ads/references/meta-decision-system.md. MIT.

Take the data gate (minimum spend before judging), the kill and keep and scale thresholds, and the creative ceiling formula. Substitute target CPA for TCPL throughout. Strip every reference to Meta's interface, campaign structures, Advantage+ and lead forms, because you cannot buy there. Retitle it so nobody later assumes it is a Meta document.

Add one line the source does not have: at the spend levels these accounts run, the data gate will frequently say "wait" for weeks. That is the correct answer and the agent should say it rather than invent a read.

2. Klaviyo flow mechanics. Extends section 2 of klaviyo-cannabis-strategist\knowledge.md

Your Klaviyo file is the strongest of the four on method and provenance. It has API revision discipline, the Placed Order proxy, metric ordering, the A/B significance guard, segment naming collisions, timezone and deliverability posture. It has zero flow timing and zero exclusion logic. Winback appears once, as the account fact that TGH flow SD5sk9 has never fired. Smart Sending, browse-abandon exclusions and flow suppression do not appear anywhere.

Two sources fill it, and they are complementary rather than overlapping:

Tag both INHERITED. The Reddit author is the founder of Aimerce and pitches a Chrome extension in the second post, so the Smart Sending and UTM claims get verified against Klaviyo's own docs before either reaches a client. Add the cannabis override yourself: replenishment cadence for flower, edibles and vapes is materially shorter than the generic ecommerce assumption those timing tables are built on, so the numbers are a starting point to override per brand from real purchase intervals, not a standard.

The UTM item is worth flagging as urgent rather than routine. Your ads knowledge base names broken UTMs as the headline defect across these accounts. This gives the Klaviyo agent a specific, checkable, per-flow version of the same defect, and it is not retroactive, so every day it stays broken is permanently unattributed send volume.

3. Resolve the conversions-per-variant conflict in cannabis-cro-strategist\knowledge.md section 6

This one is a correction, not an addition, and it is the highest-value thing on the list after the ads rules because it decides whether your CRO agent is ever allowed to propose a test.

Your section 6 currently says, INHERITED 2026-08-10, that below roughly 1,000 conversions per variant most tests are mathematically meaningless. The r/ecommerce low-volume post says 250 conversions per variation or the test is underpowered. Those differ by a factor of four, and the gap is the difference between "these accounts can run a test" and "these accounts can never run a test".

Both numbers are wrong as written, because a conversions-per-variant constant with no minimum detectable effect attached is not a number. Required conversions per variant is a function of MDE. Roughly, at 80% power and 95% confidence, detecting a 25 to 30% relative lift lands in the low hundreds per variant, a 10% lift lands in the low thousands, and a 5% lift in the many thousands. So 250 is approximately right for the radical swings the same post says are the only thing worth testing at low volume, and 1,000 is approximately right for a 10% refinement that a low-volume store should never be testing in the first place. The two sources are not actually in conflict. They are quoting the same curve at different points, and both dropped the axis.

The fix: delete the bare constant, and replace it with the MDE-indexed table from coreyhaines31/marketingskills, skills/ab-testing/references/sample-size-guide.md, MIT. Your file already sets MDE at 15 to 20% for low-traffic surfaces, so the table and your existing MDE rule finally connect to each other instead of sitting in the same section contradicting each other.

Then add the escalation ladder from the same Reddit post, which your file genuinely lacks: what to do instead when the account cannot test. Usability fixes first at zero traffic required, walk the store as a first-time buyer, check for widget and Safari JS breakage, then up from there. Your section 6 currently tells the agent to refuse and offers three options in one line. The ladder is the substantive version.

4. Cannabis objection order. Extends section 3 of cannabis-cro-strategist\knowledge.md, and feeds post-purchase copy

Source: r/weedbiz /comments/1u1b2nr/, 1,239 California dispensaries, about 890,000 Google reviews.

This is the only real cannabis customer-voice dataset in either survey, and it is the one find with no substitute anywhere. Do not paste the list. Translate it, because it is walk-in retail and about half of it does not transfer.

Transfers to ecommerce:

Does not transfer: wait times, lines, queue management, register behaviour.

5. Creative generation discipline. Extends section 8 of cannabis-ads-strategist\knowledge.md

Source: coreyhaines31/marketingskills, skills/ad-creative/references/hook-system.md. MIT.

Your section 8 is creative direction that clears review, which is a compliance filter. It does not cover how to generate genuinely different creative. Take two things only: the no-duplication rule, that hook components must complement rather than repeat each other, and the segment by motivation by format matrix that forces generation across cells instead of thirty rewordings of one angle.

An hour of work, and worth it because the standard AI failure mode is exactly the one it prevents. Ranked fifth rather than second because it is a quality improvement on output you can already produce, whereas one through four are things the agents currently cannot do.

6. One advisor file, not twelve

Source: coreyhaines31/marketingskills, skills/marketing-council/references/advisors/, the Eugene Schwartz file. MIT.

The GitHub survey recommends all twelve advisor files as shared copywriting knowledge. Do not. Your knowledge bases are disciplined, provenance-tagged and already carry copy standards, and twelve files of mid-century direct-response theory is bloat that will pull agents toward voice that is not yours.

Take one idea from one file, as a short rule: the five stages of market sophistication, and specifically that when claims are exhausted or unavailable you sell the mechanism instead. In a category where the claim is illegal, mechanism selling is not a stylistic choice, it is the only legal register available. That is worth three paragraphs in shared copy knowledge. The other eleven files are worth reading on a Sunday and are not worth installing.


Skip, and why

Everything Meta and Google tactical. Covered in the table above. Your own platform map closes those channels for these brands, and neither survey checked its finds against it. This is the largest single correction in this document.

Reddit find 6, the holdout and geo-lift post. Fully duplicative. Your ads knowledge base section 5 already says incrementality is the only ground truth, already names geo holdouts, matched-market tests and deliberate spend pauses, and already carries the better version of the caveat: design them to be readable at the account's real spend, and a holdout at $400 a month will not produce a signal. The Reddit post adds nothing you have not already written more precisely.

GrowthBook's sequential testing docs. Also duplicative. Your CRO section 6 already knows sequential testing cuts required traffic by 40 to 60%, already names VWO, Optimizely and Convert as having it, and already cites arxiv 2409.15756. The GitHub survey did not check this and recommended it as new. What GrowthBook genuinely adds is CUPED, post-stratification and multiple corrections, which are absent from your file. See the gaps section below.

Build a per-state ad-rules gate. The GitHub survey closes by recommending this as the thing your cannabis agents most need. It is already open question 7 in cannabis-ads-strategist\knowledge.md, which specifically queues California DCC advertising requirements including audience composition thresholds and licence-number display from the primary source. You queued it yourself on 2026-08-10. The only thing the Roviq Massachusetts file adds is the document shape: required verbatim warning strings, a stated audience threshold, and an explicit banned-methods list including price mentions, gifts and giveaways. Use the shape. The content is Massachusetts and does not cross a state line.

The marketingskills clone farm. Nine repos, all the same MIT files re-hosted, some with attribution stripped. Adopting any is taking a stale fork of something maintained upstream. Go to the source.

majiayu000/claude-skill-registry, jeremylongshore/claude-code-plugins-plus-skills, davila7/claude-code-templates, caishengold/ai-agent-ops, every zero-star cannabis marketing repo, every marketing prompt library repo. Volume, scrapes and templates with a word substituted. Nothing original.

Every Reddit Claude-skills listicle. Skill names with one-line descriptions and an email capture. No files. The best of them describes a client current-state file plus a brand skill loading approved claims and personas, which is what your knowledge.md files already do with better provenance.

Landing Page Office Hours corpus, the PPC SOP, the deliverability recovery post, Klaviyo 101, the abandoned-cart phone experiment. Not wrong, just low marginal value against what you have. Park the phone-call experiment as a tactic to raise for a high-AOV low-volume brand where email is constrained. It is one merchant, one period, no control, so it is an anecdote and never a benchmark.

The marketing analytics bibliography, Reddit find 2. Real value but slow. It supplies the primary papers behind the geo-experiment methods your ads file currently asserts without sources: Trimmed Match, Time Based Regression, CausalImpact, Meta GeoLift. That is a provenance upgrade, so it belongs in the cannabis-knowledge-curator reading queue and nowhere near a strategist agent. Note the fetch problem: the RSS body strips anchor hrefs, so the links have to be harvested from a browser.


Licensing

Source Licence What you may do
coreyhaines31/marketingskills MIT Adapt freely. Carry an attribution line on any KB section holding substantial adapted text.
thatrebeccarae/claude-marketing MIT, repo level and per skill Same.
growthbook/growthbook docs MIT, docs sit outside the enterprise directories Same.
Roviq-AI/agency-ops-center No licence. All rights reserved. Read once. Copy nothing. It is also live client work left public by accident.
NirvanaGuha/GrowthSkills No licence. Read the three-track architecture. Copy nothing.
archive-dot-com/creator-marketing-skills No licence. Copy nothing. Only relevant if you run creator work for hemp brands.
mcorbett51090/RavenClaude NOASSERTION Treat as no licence. Copy nothing. Dispensary retail ops, not ecommerce.
All Reddit posts User content licensed to Reddit, not to you Facts and numbers are not copyrightable. Expression is. Extract the thresholds and the mechanism, write them in your own words, cite the URL, tag INHERITED. Never paste a paragraph into a knowledge base or a client deliverable.

Practical MIT note: MIT requires the copyright and permission notice to travel with substantial portions. One attribution line at the top of any section carrying adapted text covers it. Extracting a threshold and rewriting the reasoning is derived knowledge and lighter, but attribute anyway, it costs one line.


The real gaps, where nothing good exists publicly

Cannabis and hemp marketing knowledge as agent skills does not exist. GitHub code search for cannabis and dispensary in SKILL.md files returns German criminal law, a New Jersey licence lookup, municipal permit extraction and dispensary retail operations. Everything cannabis published is compliance, seed-to-sale or law. A full year of r/weedbiz top posts is rescheduling, licensing, insurance, banking, Dutchie and Nabis complaints, wage disputes and pre-roll machines, with two marketing items in the year. r/CannabisIndustry is worse.

This is the correct and important finding of both surveys, and it is a moat rather than a failure. It also means the honest answer to the original question is: there are no cannabis CRO or cannabis ads skill files to find, on either platform, and your own account data is genuinely the best available source in this category. Not as a consolation. Your four knowledge bases, with their VERIFIED and INHERITED tagging and dated recheck rules, are already better sourced than anything published in this space.

Three things you have to write yourself, in order of how much they bind:

1. Decision thresholds at cannabis media scale. Corey's arithmetic is right and it is generic. What nobody has published is what those thresholds look like when your only reachable inventory is endemic platforms and cannabis programmatic, where CPMs, fill and audience quality are different from Meta and the minimum viable test spend is different again. That has to come from Mantis, Fyllo or Traffic Roots delivery data on your own accounts. It is the single highest-value thing your accounts can produce that nothing external can.

2. low_traffic_experimentation.md. From GrowthBook's docs/docs/statistics/, MIT, and narrowed to what you do not already have: cuped.mdx, post-stratification.mdx, multiple-corrections.mdx, power.mdx. Skip sequential.mdx, you have it. CUPED and post-stratification cut variance using pre-experiment data, which is the only real lever for an account that cannot reach n, and neither appears anywhere in your CRO file. This is documentation and not a skill, so it is condensing work.

3. The per-state ad-rules gate. Already your open question 7. Build it from state regulators directly. Roviq's Massachusetts file gives you the shape: what you cannot say, what you must append verbatim, what channels and methods are banned, what audience composition threshold applies. Texas and California first, since those govern TGH Houston and Cali Extrax.


Order of work, sized honestly

# Work Size Blocked by
1 Ad decision rules into cannabis-ads-strategist, target CPA substituted, Meta references stripped 1 hour Nothing to write it. Kill and keep half runs after the UTM fix.
2 Klaviyo flow timing, exclusions and Smart Sending into klaviyo-cannabis-strategist 1 hour Nothing. Verify the two vendor claims against Klaviyo docs before client use.
3 Fix the conversions-per-variant contradiction in CRO section 6, add the MDE table and the escalation ladder 2 hours Nothing.
4 Cannabis objection order into CRO section 3, translated not pasted, plus the post-purchase items to the Klaviyo agent 3 hours Nothing.
5 Hook generation discipline into ads section 8 1 hour Nothing.
6 Schwartz mechanism-selling rule into shared copy knowledge 30 min Nothing.
7 low_traffic_experimentation.md from GrowthBook, CUPED and post-stratification and multiple corrections only 1 day Nothing. Real condensing work.

Total genuinely worth doing: about a day and a half. Items 1 to 4 are the ones that change what an agent writes, and they are five hours between them. Do those first and stop if the day runs out.

Not worth doing at all: everything in the skip list. Park until the trigger fires: SMS and TCPA compliance from skills/sms/references/compliance.md, MIT, which is genuinely good and genuinely useless until SMS is actually switched on for one of these brands, at which point it is a 20-minute grab.

Two things to decide before item 1 can be finished, and they are questions for you, not research:


Attribution

Adapted material in this plan and in any knowledge base section that follows from it derives from coreyhaines31/marketingskills (MIT), thatrebeccarae/claude-marketing (MIT) and growthbook/growthbook documentation (MIT). Reddit material is cited by URL and paraphrased, never reproduced. Nothing was cloned, installed or added as a dependency, and no agent knowledge base was modified in producing this document.